Model A1286. Released February 2011 / 2.0, 2.2, or 2.3 GHz Quad-core Intel Core i7 Processor

375 Questions View all

Logic board fried or my magsafe dc input?

Hello, I am trying to figure out if I have a dead logic board or I just need a magsafe dc input part.

Problem

My original magsafe adapter died due to fraying. I then purchased an after market one with the highest ratings on amazon. It was going to be used until I re soldered my original. I then used the "new" after market one for about a week with zero issues. Then the other day, when the computer was about to die (less than 8 minutes left) I went to plug it in.... And computer went right off... Battery light ON CHARGER went off and only would go back on if I unplugged it from macbook pro.

Did some research and found that a handful of others also had same issue with this specific charger and basically said it fried their logic board or the charger simply failed. Also when I attempted to reconnect this after market charger again, (after trying different wall sockets that work etc) it seemed to make a zapping sound when it connected to the magsafe port on computer. When pulling it back off I saw what appeared to be slight black marks on the 2 and 4 pins inside the magsafe jack (on computer). Also noticed black marks on same pins on the aftermarket charger. Was concerned this was a sign of frying logic board or dc input jack.

Did some more research and found that other people had same issue with a variety of MacBooks and some people mentioned it was just marks from use. I clean jack and began the trouble shooting process... Bought a brand new oem 85 w Apple charger off amazon and used multimeter to test its functionality. Charger appeared to work, no other computer nearby to directly test the charger on though.

Plugged in new oem charger and same issue .... no light on magsafe connector indicating charging, also I should mentioned, that since the computer originally turned off, the battery level indicator light (on side of computer) also wasn't working and the same issue even with the new oem charger remains.

I have opened up macbook and disconnected internal battery and attempted to see if it would turn on just with charger. didn't work. I have reset the smc, didn't work, no lights no power at all. I should also mention that before all this occurred, my battery was around 80-90% life still and was holding a charge very very well.

My questions

1. Did my healthy battery somehow get fried by aftermarket charger and therefore need new battery? And wouldn't I be able to by pass this by disconnecting it and just using the oem adapter? How to I verify if battery is fried or still functional considering I don't have another computer to test it on and the fact the battery was so drained and in need of a charge when the problem occurred? is there a way to test this with the multimeter?

2. Is my Logic board fried?

3. Is my magsafe connector dc input fried?

4. What other trouble shooting steps can I do to identify issue/see which one needs replacement?

Answer this question I have this problem too

Is this a good question?

Score 1

Comments:

Does it boot off the battery you did not mention that.

by

Nope doesn't boot off battery. The battery was at like 8 minutes left just before I plggued in aftermarket charger. Once I did that, everything went off and never to come back on . Because I don't have second Mac, I can't test in other

MacBook. Also, I can not tell if battery is fried from charger like potentially the Magsafe dc in is, or the logic board for the same reason; and by now , the battery might be officially shot since I havnt been able to charge it since the initial problem .

by

I've run into a similar problem. However my macbook still works, but only with a 60w charger and not the default 85w. Did you replace the logic board?

by

I got very lucky and did some research on my 2011 macbook pro 15 in.. Found that macbook pro's from 2011 - 2013 sometimes have an issue with the gpu and cause flickering during videos / games etc... Also sometimes it just messes with (electrically) the rest of the computer. SO as a last ditch effort after getting a new magsafe port and installing it myself only to have same problem I called apple and wanted to see if they would honor that "recall repair" to my computer of which never had a apple care warranty on it. They sent me a box in the mail, I mailed comp, they replaced not only the logic board, but the keyboard, gpu, uninstalled my 8gig aftermarket ram replacing it with 8 gigs of apple ram and sent me basically my refurbished computer back to me. Total cost to me was $0....... I got REALLY LUCKY that there was a recall because without it I would have had to spend money on a new comp.

by

Add a comment

1 Answer

Most Helpful Answer

Unlikely to be battery. Most likely damage to the charging circuit on the board--which itself is generally repairable. Because of the black marks, rule out DC in board. You can find more information than you'll ever want to know on Louis Rossmann's YouTube channel on MacBook board repair. He fixes this issue every day. I wouldn't bug him with questions, but if he has time he will float over here and give you a troubleshooting plan. Alternatively, send your MacBook out for motherboard repair--most shops that do MacBook board repair have seen this classic problem many times.

Was this answer helpful?

Score 3

Comments:

Thank you, I am going to get into contact with a few places tomorrow and request quotes

For logic board repair or replacememt. Will make my way over to YouTube to check out his channel .. I believe I was on it once before ...I also understand that you think I might not have to replace logic board which I believe is $350.. You think I may just need to repair the charging circuit .. Is this correct ?

by

Add a comment

Add your answer

Justin Piciulli will be eternally grateful.
View Statistics:

Past 24 Hours: 7

Past 7 Days: 38

Past 30 Days: 85

All Time: 1,244