2.3GHz, 2.6GHz, or 2.7GHz quad-core Intel Core i7 processor (Turbo Boost up to 3.7GHz) with 6MB shared L3 cache.

277 Questions View all

t-y-u-i-o keys intermittently work SOLVED (SO FAR)

UPDATE 03-10-17 : You don't have to read the saga below if you don't want to. As was suggested to me several times by the helpful people on this site, it IS a hardware issue. Don't waste any more time and get the top case replaced. I waited until I could better afford doing so (I paid $371.00) at a local Chicagoland family owned store that's been around since the 1930's (I think) which happens to be where I purchased my macbook pro in the first place. As soon as I experienced that heat surge I should have called Abt immediately instead of blowing it off and writing it off as just an issue with having a bottom protector cover on it. I took that bottom cover off thinking it would help and did nothing because the keyboard didn't act up until a few months later. The fact that I smoke and have a cat doesn't help either of course. I was told that the cover might have had something to do with it and a heat surge like I felt can be enough to screw things up. I am still wondering whether or not a software I had at the time had anything to do with it. Two apps I've questioned were smcfan control and/or F.lux. I only mention this because about the time I had those on my machine, we would find my macbook still lit up in the morning...Usually when I fall asleep to a podcast, the screen would go dark sometime during the night but for some reason, after installing one or both of those or maybe even having some sort of update, my husband would often say he keeps seeing my screen bright and on with me asleep where he didn't used to see that before. I was slow to look into that problem too. What a big bunch of expensive lessons I have learned about my procrastination and habits! Good luck to everyone and thank you so much for this website and all you helpful people. Hope something in my posts helps SOMEBODY. end of 3/10/17 update.

Holding all the keys down at once for a while seems to get them functioning properly. I've reset the PRAM and the SMC. After my most recent reset of the SMC, the fan came on LOUD and battery was not recognized.

Apple online help insists it is a hardware issue but hardware testing reveals no issues. tried cleaning carefully to no avail.

I've reinstalled he O/S under the guidance of an apple tech and had a brand new external hard drive backing up all my crap. I told the technician I was worried that El Capitan may have caused the issue and I thought perhaps a reinstall would get me back to mavericks but it didn't. I still have el capitan. So. Other than holding down all the keys or sometimes just one of the keys for a long time, nothing else really works. All those quirky "fixes" i heard about...toggling on and off mouse keys, etc...those seem to only help other people in small numbers. I'm thinking I should take it to apple but I am concerned about the cost. I can't seem to find out more about this tier level cost saving measure for fixing macbook pro mid-2012. Wish i could get some estimates before I trek out there with this thing. I read that one person in another country after a long phone call got repairs done FREE but that tech I spoke with didn't seem interested in that. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

Update (12/24/2016)

HELLO. I just want to report that after months of agonizing, abandoning, and then going back to trying things like SMC/PRAM resetting, reinstalling O/S, and popping out keys now and then to clean, I decided to wait until I had uninterrupted time in a perfectly sunlit room. I waited until my husband left essentially since i'm too easily distracted. I got every kind of key popping tool I could come up with. I'm STILL scared of doing it because I don't know if static can screw things up. I ended up using special toothpicks...the fancy ones...the triangular shaped G.U.M. ones, a little spatula for women's facial wax (don't ask), new unused eyeshadow brushes, super strong reading glasses, tweezers, and yes, my Dyson vacuum. I figured since it was seeming like I was going to have to pay through the nose to repair anyway, may as well risk causing the damage and hope they don't tell me what damage I caused with this step and how much this step cost me extra in dollars.

Well...somewhere I read in response to those who's " r-t-y-u-i" keys intermittently not responding or lagging, someone suggested cleaning the "e" key...They said they learned that the "E" key can be dirty, affecting other keys, even though "E" types fine. Essentially, the advice was to clean keys to the left of the problem keys. It's a strange problem because the keys intermittently don't work but I eventually figured out that they DID work, they just LAGGED...LAGGED BY A LOT OF SECONDS sometimes but DID work. Puzzling. Felt so much like a software issue since El Capitan was installed just prior to the problem. Then I though well...swollen battery seems to make sense too.. I seem to remember a great deal of HEAT that seemed not right...so much so that I felt it was wise to take the bottom protective add-on case off my macbook pro. I still have the top one on but I thought the plastic was perhaps insulating it too much even though it's made by apple. Heat still occurred. I recall even downloading an app for gamers...smc fan controller to control your fan when you want to cool things off. That seemed to help. I wondered if El Capitan's upgrade was incompatible with that app. Don't know.

Back to the "E" key. There it was...a cat hair. I cleaned a few other keys in that row..."P" key still loose since I cracked something on many of my cleanings but it's been about three days and the problem has NOT returned. I am including ALL this info in the hopes that others with the same problem can find this SOLVED post through keyword searches that appear in this wordy post. So, in conclusion, a key that works might be dirty and making other keys that are clean NOT work. Hope this all makes sense.

Answered! View the answer I have this problem too

Is this a good question?

Score 0

Comments:

Incidentally. When I look back at the timeline, had I brought the macbook in at the first suspicion of the bottom feeling too hot, I would have been within the warranty. FYI. As soon as something doesn't seem right, CALL APPLE get documentation.

by

Wow! I have been looking around a lot for a solution. I had the issue with the same keys (t, y, u, i, and o). Cleaning out fuzz and dust under E seems to have restored y, u, i, and o, but I am now having some R lag. I don't think R was a problem key before but maybe it just wasn't as bad as the others.

To further clarify the issue, for example, when typing the word "further", the R's /sometimes/ don't come out unless I hold R for a bit. (So I'll get "furthe", and then have to go back to the end of it and hold R). It used to be this way on the other keys too. I will most likely clean either under E or R directly again to try to fix this.

I would guess the same thing that you concluded, that the keys to the left can be responsible for the issue. It's also worth noting that I've had some issues with my E and R keys in the past (the physical key caps) and I've had to replace them, so that may be how they attracted so much dirt and fuzz under them.

by

My problem returned.. Decided to get into a well lit room again with brand new cans of canned air and a new set of LED lit magnifying glasses which were a big help. Cleaned up the e, r,t,y,u,i.o keys but stopped when I discovered I officially broke the keycap for "y". Things seem to be typing ok aside from that. A recent thing I tried was simultaneously pressing the r and t keys..What a great fix that was for about an hour or so. This is so frustrating. I might just get it fixed. Too frustrated to do it myself. What's the cheapest option for top case replacement? What is the cheapest place to get individual key caps because I believe I need a y and a p. Thank you

by

vgm, I've decided to give up with the key popping. I replaced some keys I broke in the process of troubleshooting and I will take mine to a place near me called Abt. Whenever it is I can afford to do this, I will be sure to report what I'm told is the ultimate cause of such a weird intermittent issue. Thanks everyone.

by

My problem has somewhat returned too! Now every so often T, U or O will just stop working until I press them a lot, and my R likes to send itself multiple times. It happens a lot less frequently now though. I was going to try to clean under a bunch more keys, which I hope helps again.

In regards to where to buy keycaps, I've previously purchased a full Macbook Pro keyboard from ebay, since I'm awful at pulling them off. I paid $10 for mine used, but I've seen them go for $20 new. You have to be careful to get the same model too, since sometimes the mechanism underneath varies slightly. I like this cause it gives me some insurance to be more reckless pulling off keys.

by

Show 1 more comment

Add a comment

3 Answers

Chosen Solution

I agree with Reece about it being liquid damage. But my solution is to first hook up an external keyboard and see if it works right. If so the keyboard may be your only issue. It can be replaced. It's about 2 1/2 job for a novice.

Here is a guide for doing on a 2010, which is almost identical to the 2012.

MacBook Pro 13" Unibody Mid 2010 Keyboard Replacement

Was this answer helpful?

Score 4

Comments:

@mayer good advice, but their model is the 2012 15" Retina, so they will have to remove the rivets to do this. I think the keyboard has got an issue, but it is definitely worth cleaning any liquid before as you have said, since it caused issues with high fan spin and not recognising the battery

by

@reecee I missed that it was a Retina, which is a real PITA to replace. I'll see if I can find a guide for replacing that one. I did replace the pegs with screws.

by

actually in attempt to fix the issue, i reset the SMC which i try from time to time only, this last time, the fan went berserk as did the battery recognition....resetting again fixed that fan issue...that freaked me out.

by

Add a comment

Sounds like liquid damage. Remove the logic board and clean it if there is any green/blue corrosion. Check the battery PCB for liquid too.

If this sounds out of your depth, would recommend using a good 3rd party repair centre (a lot cheaper, and can repair the logic board instead of replacing). Don't have any idea of cost with Apple, but @mayer should have an idea :)

Was this answer helpful?

Score 3
Add a comment

I had an issue like this try typing without the bottom case on sometime the bottom case can short out the keyboard pins

Was this answer helpful?

Score -1

Comments:

interesting. I might try this. Thank you.

by

Add a comment

Add your answer

geni499 will be eternally grateful.
View Statistics:

Past 24 Hours: 1

Past 7 Days: 12

Past 30 Days: 33

All Time: 218