Model A1297 Unibody: Early 2009, Mid 2009, Mid 2010 & Late 2011

425 Questions View all

How much work would it be to convert a 2009 to 2010?

Hello.

So I have my 2009 MBP 17" here and it needs repair. However, it's sitting here dead. I still have it but I never repaired it yet. The reason for this is it's 6 years old and I really cannot buy the parts I need. I've mentioned this before too.

Since I clearly can't find 2009 parts that easily(and even if I could they're still well loved or cost more then another 2009) I have a better idea. I'll see about converting my "2009" MacBook Pro to a "2010" model. This seems like the easiest way out of my issue, especially since first generation Intel core i series processors are still very good chips. The onboard video this generation is crap, but these have dual video systems.

Now, I know I need a battery and hard drive too. I also need the bottom cover and screws. I may also take the opportunity to install a BD-R drive in the laptop too. That's up for debate though. The hard drive has 88/100 reallocated sectors, so I'd plan on replacing it too.

How much would it cost to get the 2010 motherboard and battery to do the transplant and will I need to change anything else in the computer? It seems like a 2010 transplant will be the easiest since it's only a new year newer then what I have now. However, if I was going from a 2009 to a 2011 I would essentially need to rebuild my machine. Not to mention if my video card died I'm screwed. For this reason I'd prefer to do a 2009->2010 swap.

Answered! View the answer I have this problem too

Is this a good question?

Score 1
Add a comment

1 Answer

Chosen Solution

Too much work and not worth it.

You can just buy a 2010 machine that works for $700 or $800.

Or you could torture yourself buying a motherboard, a wifi card, a wifi cable, a new webcam, a new webcam cable, a new lcd back cover to fit the different wifi antenna and webcam.... don't go down this &&^&@@ up road. Please.

You have to rebuild your laptop anyway. 2009 to 2010 will require rebuilding. 2009 to 2011 will only require you get a new battery in addition to everything I mentioned prior. Also you'll need a BGA rework machine to replace that &&^&@@ up AMD graphics chip every three to six months as it dies.

This will end in a nightmare because every step of the way you will be buying a used part pulled out of a broken computer on eBay or Amazon or PBM, and with each purchase is the risk they send you the wrong $@$*, or a dead part, or something that winds up turning this entire job into a nightmare.

Was this answer helpful?

Score 1

Comments:

I was hoping this was as easy as a new motherboard and battery(and a KB. The domes are starting to fail.) to bring my 2009 back for a passable amount to make it happen. My plan B was to use this for a parts machine and clone my old drive to a new one. The drive in it now has 88/100 bad sectors so the drive needs to go too. The only part(s) left worth a thing are the Unibody(with a new KB) and the LCD. DVD drive is flaky. I'm not buying a 2011 Pro. I'd rather avoid that AMD video card nonsense.

by

You are looking at replacing every part in a six year old computer. It's time to buy another one. :(

by

I have found 2009 boards new from Powerbook Medic but the problem is the C2D MBP is 6 years old and anything left is NOS boards or it's refurb boards that died and were repaired by Apple. It's that or it's been repaired in a garage or came from a crappy 2009 like mine. Not going down that road for parts. As I said I'm better off moving up to a Core i series 17"(hence my hope this is possible). I should also note putting this off got me a Haswell laptop. I'd get another Mac for things that need it at the most.

by

New motherboard for a six year old discontinued laptop? Sounds like a bunch of BS to me! But when you look at the results.. http://www.yelp.com/biz/powerbook-medic-... yeah no surprise there.

Don't spend more than $300 on a board for this, anyone calling it new is selling recycled refurbished trash or used old $@$* and calling it new to collect top dollar on it which is shameful. There are NO new sources to MCP79 based motherboards!!!

by

Even if you did, anything you find has probably been in a laptop used by professionals who bang this crap around, kept the stock Apple thermal paste and probably never cleaned out the fans in this thing. Because of that, any board I buy to replace it is going to be well loved and will probably have nastier problems down the road. The machine seemed like a money pit 6 years in. I can't even find batteries for it outside of Chinese clones.

by

Add a comment

Add your answer

Nick will be eternally grateful.
View Statistics:

Past 24 Hours: 0

Past 7 Days: 0

Past 30 Days: 0

All Time: 100