Released June 2009 / 2.66, 2.8, or 3.06 GHz Core 2 Duo Processor

273 Questions View all

Is this SSD compatible with my computer?

I want to upgrade my mid 09 mbp's hdd for a newer ssd. I was just going to buy one from Crucial (MX100), but it seems the Samsung 850 EVO is a bit faster. Will the Samsung model work with this macbook? Do you think its worth the extra money?

Thanks.

Answer this question I have this problem too

Is this a good question?

Score 1
Add a comment

2 Answers

Most Helpful Answer

Short answer. Yes

If you have problems follow the steps below previously posted.

A new internal drive normally ships unformatted. Unless the operating system on the old boot drive posts a dialog box offering to format the unrecognized drive, the computer doesn't "detect" anything because there isn't anything the operating system can speak to yet.

Of course, if the way you installed this SSD was to remove the previous internal HD and install the SSD in its place, without formatting the new SSD and installing a bootable operating system first, then there's no operating system or formatting utility at all.

What steps have you already taken? If you can give us a detailed list of the things you've already done, in order, it will be easier to determine where the problem is.

A common technique to replace an internal boot HD with an SSD would be to:

attach the SSD as an external drive first through USB/FireWire/ Thunderbolt

use Disk Utility to format the SSD

clone the operating system+user data from the internal HD to the external SSD using Disk Utility, SuperDuper! or Carbon Copy Cloner (you can also do a clean operating system install by downloading an installer from the App Store and installing it on the new drive)

then open up the computer and swap the drives

That way, once you restart the reassembled computer, you can at least be sure that there's a drive with a bootable operating system available. If you're following the technique I've outlined, it's wise to try booting from the new external SSD before installing it internally, just to make sure the computer recognizes the drive as bootable.

Thanks, this makes sense but I do not have a casing to use to attach the drive to my computer. However I do have 2 computers so I'm wondering if I can format it by connecting the computer with the unformatted drive to the other computer through Firewire? I seem to remember that to do this you hold down T when turning on ?

That's correct. You start the computer-as-external hard drive while holding down the T key as you power up. If it works, you should see a FireWire icon bopping around on the target machine's display. I assume the same technique works with Thunderbolt, but I've never had the opportunity to try it. I've also never tried to mount a computer with an unformatted drive as a target drive, but I don't see why this shouldn't work. I hope you'll report back and let us know if this works...In future, an external SATA-FW or SATA-USB interface is a handy thing to have around.

it worked with Firewire ! Thanks so much. Only I have another problem... that is very wierd. I restored from a Timeline backup and it doesn't accept my password to login that I have been using for the past 10 years! I have racked my brain and can't work out how it could have changed. Has this happened to anyone else?

Original post: New SSD not detected

Was this answer helpful?

Score 2
Add a comment

Both hard drives are capable of working in your MBP mid 2009. Both hard drives may need to have a jumper moved to limit their IO speed, throttle them down. The original firmware in your MacBook Pro limited the data transfer rate of the hard drive to SATA 1 - 1.5Gbs. Thus, you might not realize anything but the internal read/write speeds and not get the most out of your investment. There was a firmware patch that allowed this laptop to have up to SATA 2 - 3Gbs transfer speeds on the SATA IO channel. That can be found here. Even after installing the updated firmware many owners of this laptop did not get the 3GBs transfer from their hard drive(s). That topic is touched on here. On threads in the Apple Support Communities, that have been erased (ones I know of anyways), Apple basically says they don't support 3rd party drives.

I would not recommend purchasing either of these hard drives. You own an Apple, akin to a Farrari, they are temperamental about upgrades. You don't own a Chevy that loves every aftermarket part you throw at it. There is a hard drive mentioned Can I use a SATA III drive at SATA II specs? That is supposed to work at the 3Gbs IO transfer rate. You might want to ask another question with what SSD hard drives will give SATA 2, 3Gbs transfer rates with this machine. I don't have that information in front of me at the moment. I am certain others on here will. Good Luck

Was this answer helpful?

Score 1
Add a comment

Add your answer

Andrew will be eternally grateful.
View Statistics:

Past 24 Hours: 7

Past 7 Days: 64

Past 30 Days: 168

All Time: 11,393