We had this exact same issue. When I contacted Xbox support, they told me that many of the Xbox One wireless controllers are infact faulty. We have had to send ours back to Microsoft and WE ARE STILL WAITING for our replacement to be sent, this has been over a month now that we have been waiting!! very frustrating!!
Reputation over time
It looks like this user hasn't gained any reputation yet.
Once they have, you'll be able to view a graph of their reputation gained over time.
Here's a preview of what the graph will look like: