I replaced logicboard but the ethernet doesn't always work.

I bought a liquid damaged macbook (a1342 2009) and also from someone else a logic board. I succesfully replaced the logic board with the other one, and it booted again. I now type this from that Macbook.

However, I made sure to test everything, and my ethernet won't work. It always says "Cable Unplugged", also when plugged in. When I put the cable into my original macbook, it immediately connects ok, so the cable is fine.

I read this has to do with the logicboard, and I am afraid I need to return it to my seller. Is there anything I could have done wrong that made the ethernet fail? (I don't t know of anything that affects it?) What could I try to get it working?

I do run OSX 10.7, so the mac should be supported fully.

==Update==

I tried another network cable, and suddenly it did work. But after I wiggle a tiny bit with that cable the connection gets lost, and I need to plug out and plug in again. So still not really working as it should. On my original Macbook, this would not cause disconnection.

Answered! View the answer I have this problem too

Is this a good question?

Score 0
Add a comment

1 Answer

Chosen Solution

Look in the port with a magnifying light to see if there is any debris or corrosion or the pins are bent out of alignment.

Was this answer helpful?

Score 2

Comments:

Thanks, will do that. I found out that if you press real hard with the cable it reconnects again. Maybe the pins are to little bending back or so, and thus disconnect. Going to look with a good lamp tomorrow.

by

I checked it, removed dust, but I can see that the metal pins inside the port do not all spring back to top position. Some remain at 75% height. I tried to poke them up and down to see if I could remove more dust, but to no avail.

I checked my 2 other macbooks and they all had the pins fully sprong back. I guess it's an issue with this logic board.

I am contemplating cleaning it by submerging it in isopropyl or so, but since I possible need to return this board to my seller and I am not sure if it won't damage it, I think it's not really fixable.

by

Don't alter the contact wires inside the connector! they are designed this way.

by

As this is a replacement board I would return it. It sounds like you have a cold solder joint at the connector (bad board).

by

Well, if I check my other logic boards, there the pins do all sit in 100% top position, this one has 2 that don't. I doubt it's a solder joint issue. Any way, I will indeed return it. Seller told me that he normally doesn't test ethernet ports, and agreed to take it back.

by

Show 1 more comment

Add a comment

Add your answer

Peterdk will be eternally grateful.
View Statistics:

Past 24 Hours: 0

Past 7 Days: 0

Past 30 Days: 1

All Time: 231