1

Score

Avatar
dburr
23

Asked

Any problems with large hard drives and the 13" MBP?

History

I recently installed a large hard drive in my 13" unibody MacBook Pro Mid-2009. The drive I put in is a Western Digital Scorpio Black 750 GB. I am having all manner of difficulty with my machine now, where it is doing random weird things. Like, once it would not let me copy any files, even if I logged in as an admin. Another time I shut down the machine as normal (absolutely no issues whatsoever, completely normal shutdown like I've done countless times before), but when I came back to it several hours later, it refused to boot (gray screen with a flashing question mark). I booted from an OS X install DVD and was able to repair my disk using disk utility (it came up with some filesystem errors) and the system booted again. Etc.

In attempting to resolve these issues I found some talk online where other people are having problems with drives greater than 500 GB. Some of the messages mentioned my drive (the WD Scorpio Black) specifically, so I tried a different large drive (Hitachi Travelstar 750 GB). And since the last time I tried this I had cloned my system using SuperDuper, I thought maybe that was the problem, so this time around I instead did a complete OS install from scratch. The system performs much better now (seems faster, etc.) AND it has been much more stable. Until now. Twice in the past few weeks the machine has randomly and spontaneously logged me out. I have watched this happen once - I had left the machine idle, doing literally nothing, no programs other than Finder and a few menu bar extras open, and then suddenly the system goes back to the login screen. When I log back in again all of my startup items are no longer set to start up, so I have to go through and re-add them to the Login Items list in system preferences). I looked up this issue and see that though rare it does happen to a fair number of people. The funny thing is that until now this has never happened to me.

Anyway my point here is this: does anyone know of any problems between my 13" unibody MBP mid-2009, and large (>500GB) hard drives? Or is there some other issue at work here? Or am I just being paranoid over nothing? I don't want to, for example, be in the middle of editing something in Final Cut or GarageBand and have the machine suddenly log me out and lose my work, which is what concerns me here.

Edited by: oldturkey03 ( ) , Andrew Optimus Goldberg ( )

Post Answer

1

Score

Avatar
mayer
199.6k

Answered

Accepted Answer

PermalinkHistory

If it were mine, I'd reformat the drive and use the "write zeros" option to map out any possible bad blocks.

1

Score

Avatar
rj713
70.9k

Answered

PermalinkHistory

Hi, Checking MacTracker I find the largest drive from Apple was 500 MB but that should not preclude your using your current drive. The only thing I did find is a firmware update--EFI firmware update 1.7. You might want to check and see what level firmware you have--it MAY help with your problem but there are no guarantees. If you do decide to update read the instructions carefully-- a firmware update can brick a logic board. The easy answer is to install a 500 GB drive and put your 750 GB in an external case and download your finished edits to it to insure room on the system drive. Good luck. Anyone with a better answer please speak up.

0

Score

Avatar
jonathan12
13

Answered

PermalinkHistory

Sorry for the late reply, but it's not the size of the drive. I've had a 750GB drive in my mid-2009 MBP for 1.5 years now without issue. The behavior you're describing is most likely due to a faulty Hard Drive Cable. The first story at the bottom of the iFixit page for this cable in question described a fellow who "found this model notorious for the board drive cable going bad." Dozens and dozens of others have experienced almost identical behavior — in this iFixit forum — in addition to this forum on Apple Discussions, as well as this one. RECOMMENDATION: Do the most important test first: Remove the drive and see if it functions — either in another unit or as an external drive, with a SATA to USB interface or similar. If it does, then erasing the hard drive and/or reformatting it will not only prove ineffective, but unnecessary. Just replace the hard drive cable (in my case it was this one) and you should be all set.

Product Image

MacBook Pro 13" Unibody (Model A1278 Mid 2009/Mid 2010)...

Fix an unrecognized drive in your MacBook. Connects hard drive to logic board. Replacement SATA cable compatible with all Mid 2009 and Mid 2010 13" Unibody MacBook Pros. Options with or without bracket. — 16 available at 59.95 each.

Add Your Answer

View Statistics:

Today: 0

This Week: 4

This Month: 15

All Time: 739